I don’t really talk to strangers much. Maybe because I have some social anxiety that prevents it. Maybe because I learned about Stranger Danger when I was kid—you remember: mustachioed guy with Mars bars offering rides home in his windowless van.
But one place I always found it easy to strike up conversations with people I didn’t know was the dog park. I used to go there all the time when my dogs were younger, and something about being in a fenced-in space watching these lovable beings running around, and slobbering, and pooping, makes people want to share with others about how their specific dog runs around, and slobbers, and poops.
So one day, I was chatting with a stranger—I’m sure—about the minutiae of our dogs’ bowel movements, when somehow we got off on a different topic. We started talking about creamsicles. You know what those are, right?
I don’t know about you, but when I was a kid and I’d hear popsicles, I’d be like, “Ooooh!” but if they turned out to be creamsicles, I was all
Good god. They were the best.
Anyway, this particular stranger said, “You know, Arby’s has a creamsicle milkshake.”
STOP.
WUT.
Now I was at the dog park in Carrboro when this happened, and if you’ve ever been there, you know there’s an Arby’s, like, a quarter of a mile away. And I was like, Fuuuuuuuuuuuck this place—I’m out. I loaded up my dogs and headed for the drive-thru.
I wasn’t familiar with Arby’s menu—I mean, is anybody? Does ANYBODY go to Arby’s? Be honest, how many of you have been to Arby’s in the last month?
No, it’s definitely a nationwide drug front.
Anyway, I got some kind of sandwich and some fries—you know to balance out the meal—and the motherfucking creamsicle milkshake.
I only ate about half the sandwich and half the fries because they were just OK, but when I tell you the creamsicle milkshake… was a creamsicle milkshake—listen, it was a creamsicle… but also a milkshake. I was in dire ice cream headache pain but could not stop slurping it down. Thing was gone in 2½ minutes.
I lived in Hillsborough at the time, so I went home, dropped the dogs off, and headed to Durham to go out for the night. So I was on I-85 headed east when the stomach cramp hit me. It was one of those that makes you kind of stand up out of your seat, as if you might be able to get away from it?
And I was scared because I was on that stretch of highway between Hillsborough and Durham where there are no exits whatsoever. Hoping that the cramp was a one-off, I settled back into my seat, but alas. Alas! My guts started convulsing inside me. I hit the gas pedal. I needed to make it to Route 70, and I needed to do a very rude thing indeed to some poor gas station’s bathroom. I sped towards Durham, but it became VERY clear VERY soon that I was just not. going. to make it.
And that’s a weird moment, you know? When you realize that in a very short time you’re going to be a person who has shat in the woods next to the highway.
For the rest of your life.
You can’t un-become that person.
Forever and ever, if you find yourself in a game of I Never, and somebody says, “I’ve never dropped a roadside deuce,” you’re going to have to drink. It’s very humbling.
But I didn’t really have time to consider what was happening. I pulled off the interstate, grabbed some napkins from the Arby’s bag still in the front seat, and sprinted—as much as one can sprint while squeezing her ass cheeks together—into the woods.
Now I grew up in the country, just down yonder from Mr. Proffitt’s cattle farm, so I know of which I’m about to speak. When I say what came out of my body was a cowpie, I mean, in circumference, height, volume, consistency, everything—
’twas a cow pie.
Like, have you ever taken a shit so big that, when you stood up, you were off-balance? That’s how it was. Like all my organs had shifted to make room for it and now they had to slide back into place.
I staggered back to my car and made it home, and everything was totally fine—I didn’t end up in the ER or anything–but the take-away, of course, is that Stranger Danger is not always a dude in a van with candy. Sometimes it’s a friendly person at the dog park with advice about fast food.
**********
That, Amy Scott, is hilarious. If it makes you feel any better, I would drink, too. And I must know, did you ever have another creamsicle milkshake? Because sadly, despite an experience like that, if it were good enough, I would have one again.
OMG this made me laugh so effing hard! Should have just had the milkshake. No need for balance…you want a shake, have it. Just having the shake and not the rest is calorie smart. It was probably the fries. Blame the fries.
I love this story, but I wonder what makes you tell it years later? Did something happen this weekend that sent you back into your post-traumatic poop disorder?
Nah, my bowels are in tip-top shape, Dan. I recently hosted a StorySLAM with the theme of Stranger, and I remembered this little incident.
Please, do the world a favor and write a book. This is the funniest thing I’ve read in a long while and I would love 100 more pages. I do have one question. Have you been back for a second Creamsicle milkshake?
Thank you, friends. I’ve never again had the creamsicle milkshake… though there is an Arby’s on my drive home from work…
If you like the story, feel free to share it on your various social media accounts, thanks.
So to tag on to what Dave says, when ARE you writing that book? Huh? Can’t hear you?
This is pure joy.
I’m in the middle of a very sad month and being able to read one of the best anecdotes ever has given me a pause of much needed joy. Thanks so incredibly much for broadcasting your hilarious agony to refresh how comical life is!
This was an absolute perfect reading at a moment I was feeling a bit down. This snapped me right back into place. OH internet you are the greatest.
Glad you enjoyed it, Nick! Thanks.
Oh how, I love my Friday night Avid Bruxist reads. This was great Amy.
we just got home and bruce said, “really. i can not do it justice. you just have to read it yourself. go look it up on avid bruxist.” …because i couldn’t believe that i didn’t remember this story?! the one he had been raving about for 3 hours now.
i searched the AB archives for “cowpie” and found it.
and I AM SO HAPPY I DID.
“’twas a cowpie” … hahahahahahah.
i love you.
i am going to need to see you do the running man the next time we are together.
thank you.
I will running man the shit out of some running man for you.
Hey. Came over from Five Star Roundup. I’d unfortunately have to drink, too. Cheers and thanks for this great snort-laugh inducing post.
Please provide me with more details on the topic
I’d should check with you here. Which is not something I normally do! I get pleasure from reading a put up that can make people think. Also, thanks for permitting me to remark!